Skip to main content

CourtPay: Responding to a Dispute

What to Expect When a Dispute Comes In and How to Respond with Confidence

Written by Mari Bern

Introduction

Feature Summary: While disputes are an unfortunate part of accepting card payments, most can be handled with a few clear steps. This guide explains what to expect when one comes in and how to respond with confidence.

Use Cases:

  • What a dispute is

  • Rebuttal or accept

  • How to respond

  • Evidence to include, by dispute reason

  • Preventing disputes


What a Dispute Is

A dispute occurs when a member requests that their bank reverse a charge. Merchants typically have between 7 and 21 days to respond, depending on the card network. Because a missed deadline results in an automatic loss, every dispute should be addressed promptly.

Disputes come in two stages:

  • Inquiry. The bank asks for information before deciding whether to open a formal dispute. No money is taken yet. Respond to it or refund the member; an ignored inquiry often becomes a chargeback that's very hard to win.

  • Chargeback. A formal dispute. The disputed amount and a $15 dispute fee are taken from your CourtPay balance right away and held until the bank decides. Countering adds a $15 counter fee, which is returned if you win.

CourtReserve and Stripe don't decide disputes. We pass your evidence to the member's bank, and the bank makes a single, final decision.


Dispute Lifecycle

Only a dispute you counter before the deadline reaches a bank review; accepting it or letting the deadline pass ends in a loss.


Rebuttal or Accept

Counter a dispute when you can prove the member received what they paid for; accept it when the member has a point or the evidence isn't there.

Counter the Dispute When

Accept the Dispute When

The member booked and used the court, class or program

The member was charged twice or charged the wrong amount

The member agreed to your membership terms or cancellation policy

The member canceled correctly and was charged anyway

You have messages showing the member approved the charge

The session or service didn't happen

The amount is worth the time to respond

The amount is small and you have little evidence

Talk to the member first. Many disputes are misunderstandings, such as a member not recognizing the charge on their statement. If the member agrees to withdraw the dispute, still submit your evidence, including that conversation; a withdrawal alone doesn't guarantee you'll win.

Don't refund a charged-back payment. In a chargeback, the bank has already returned the money to the member, so a refund would pay them twice. At the inquiry stage, a refund is fine and closes the inquiry.


How to Respond

You get one submission per dispute, so gather everything before you send it.

  1. Watch for new disputes. Monitor for new disputes and inquiries in CourtReserve from the Disputes tab (CourtPay > Disputes).

    The Disputes tab lists each dispute’s Respond by deadline, Status, Reason, and Disputed amount. To find disputes that need a response, filter by Status or Respond by.
    ​

  2. Open the dispute. Click a dispute to open it and note:

    • The amount

    • The reason

    • The response deadline

  3. Look up the member and the charge. Pull the booking, membership or program record behind the payment.

  4. Contact the member. Try to resolve the issue directly before you respond.

  5. Decide to counter or accept. Use the guidance in Fight or accept.

  6. Gather evidence for the dispute reason. See Evidence to include below.

  7. Submit before the deadline. Write a short summary, attach your evidence and submit it from the dispute in the Disputes tab in CourtReserve before the response deadline.

If an inquiry later becomes a chargeback, you need to respond again.


Evidence to Include, by Dispute Reason

Match your evidence to the reason the member gave; evidence that answers a different claim won't help.

Dispute Reason

What the Member Is Saying

Evidence That Helps

Fraudulent

"I didn't make this payment."

Member profile showing the cardholder's name and email; booking and check-in history; earlier undisputed payments from the same card

Unrecognized

"I don't recognize this charge."

Receipt with your club name; the booking or membership record; how your name appears on statements

Duplicate

"I was charged twice."

Records showing two separate purchases (different bookings or dates), or proof the duplicate was already refunded

Subscription canceled

"I canceled my membership."

Membership agreement and cancellation policy the member accepted; proof they didn't cancel per the policy; activity after the claimed cancel date

Product not received

"I didn't get what I paid for."

Booking confirmation; check-in, attendance or court access records; coach or staff notes

Product unacceptable

"It wasn't as described."

The program or session description shown at purchase; proof it was delivered as described; your messages with the member

Credit not processed

"I was promised a refund."

Your refund policy as accepted at checkout; proof the refund was issued, or why the charge wasn't eligible

General

Anything else

Whatever shows the charge was valid and the member got what they paid for


Tips for a Strong Response

Bank reviewers handle many cases a day, so a short, organized response wins more often than a long one.

  • Lead with a summary. Two or three sentences: what the member bought, when, and why the charge is valid.

  • Answer the reason given. If the claim is "I canceled," focus on your cancellation policy and their account history, not on proving who they are.

  • Label every file. For example, "Membership agreement signed March 3" or "Check-in log, April visits."

  • Attach, don't link. Banks won't open links or outside content, so include screenshots or files instead.

  • Stay factual. Leave out frustration or opinions about the member.

  • Highlight what matters. Circle or note the relevant line in a screenshot so the reviewer finds it fast.


After You Submit

The member's bank usually takes 14 to 45 days to decide, and the disputed amount stays held until then.

To check on a dispute after you submit, open it from the Disputes tab. The Timeline shows each step and when the bank is expected to respond.

Outcome

What Happens to the Money

Won

The disputed amount is returned to your CourtPay balance and goes out in a future payout

Lost

The member keeps the disputed amount

Accepted, or deadline missed

Treated as a loss; the member keeps the disputed amount

Withdrawn by the member

Not automatically a win; it can still be lost if you didn't submit evidence

Fees. A $15 dispute fee is charged when a dispute opens and isn't refunded, even if you win. Countering adds a $15 counter fee, which is refunded if you win.

In your reports. A chargeback shows as a dispute line in your payout and balance reports, and a won dispute shows as a dispute_reversal when the money comes back.


Preventing Disputes

The cheapest dispute is the one that never happens, and most start as confusion rather than fraud.

  • Use a recognizable statement name. Members should see your club's name, not a parent company, on their card statement.

  • Show your policies at checkout. Make cancellation, refund and membership terms visible and require members to accept them.

  • Send receipts and reminders. Confirm every booking, and remind members before a membership renews.

  • Make canceling easy. A member who can't figure out how to cancel often calls their bank instead.

  • Answer complaints quickly. A fast refund for a valid complaint costs less than a dispute fee.

  • Keep records. Save check-ins, signed agreements and member messages, so evidence is ready if you need it.

Did this answer your question?